Keeping your baby away, called “Elimination Communication” in English, means: You recognize your baby’s signals and give him the opportunity to eliminate outside of the diaper. Does that sound like a lot of effort? It doesn't have to be. Because cloth diapers and holding things complement each other perfectly.
Reading time: 8 minutes
In this article you'll learn how to start holding off, what signals your baby is sending and why cloth diapers are the ideal backup. You'll see: Diaper-free doesn't have to be everything or nothing.## What does “diaper-free” really mean?The term “diaper-free” is often misleading. It's not about giving up diapers completely. The English term “Elimination Communication” describes it better.
The principle: Babies communicate from birth when they need to eliminate. They grunt, become restless or suddenly stop their play. Responding to these signals and holding your baby over a potty or toilet can help him relieve himself there.
The exciting thing is that in most cultures around the world, this is exactly the normal way. Only in Western countries have we virtually "abolished" this natural communication with disposable diapers - only to then have to laboriously train it again at the age of two or three.
TIP: You don't have to hold off 100 percent of the time. “Part-time diaper-free” – i.e. using a diaper as a backup in certain situations – also brings many advantages.## Why cloth diapers and holding are ideally complementaryMany parents think: Either diaper-free or cloth diapers. In fact, the combination of the two is the best of both worlds.
Cloth diapers as a perfect backup
Sometimes things go wrong when you're holding something - that's completely normal. Cloth diapers reliably catch small mishaps without creating a mountain of waste. And if you don't have the time or energy to hold it? Then you simply use the cloth diaper as usual.
Less laundry by staying away
Those who stay regularly have fewer wet diapers. This means: you need less suction material and have less laundry. Some parents get by with just 2-3 diapers a day - instead of the usual 6-8.
Special holding diapers make it easy
There are cloth diapers that are specifically designed for diaper-free use. So-called minimal diapers only consist of a waist belt and a bar. You can open it in a flash when your baby shows signals. The most famous are:
- MokoMidi/MokoMini: The classic among minimal diapers
- Prefold outer shells: Outer shells with a thin insert - in the event of a breakdown, you only need to change the insert
- Pull-Up Cloth Diapers: Can be pulled up and down like underwear
- Wool outer shells with slit: Wool is breathable and has self-cleaning properties
The natural wetness feedback is retained
In contrast to disposable diapers, your baby feels the moisture in cloth diapers. This is not a disadvantage – on the contrary. This means your baby retains a sense of its excretions and does not lose its natural body awareness.## Recognize your baby's signalsEvery baby communicates differently. But there are typical signs that indicate a need to eliminate:
- Sudden restlessness or fidgetiness
- Brief pause in the middle of the game
- Grunting, whining or making special noises
- Tensing the body
- Staring or “appearing absent”
- Docking and undocking when breastfeeding
- Waking up from sleep
- Red head or strained facial expression
TIP: Keep a small diary for the first few days. Note when your baby eliminates and what behavior you observed beforehand. After a few days you will recognize patterns.
Use standard situations
In addition to the individual signals, there are situations in which babies almost always have to:
- After waking up (even after a short nap)
- During or shortly after breastfeeding/feeding
- When changing (why do babies pee so often on the changing table? Because the fresh air on the bottom is a natural trigger)
- After wearing in the carrier or in the sling
- During transitions (coming home, moving out)
These standard situations are the perfect introduction. You don't have to constantly pay attention to signals - just pause in these moments and see what happens.## This is how you hold your baby properlyThe holding itself is easier than expected. The classic position:
- Take your baby in your arms with your back leaning against your stomach
- Grip under your thighs with both hands and keep your legs slightly bent
- Hold your baby over a potty, sink or toilet
- Give a key signal - for example "Psssss" or "Pee"
- Wait patiently – some babies need a moment to relax
The key signal is important: After a while, your baby associates this sound with eliminating. It learns to relax in response to the signal.
Different positions for different situations
- Newborns: Lying in your arms (similar to breastfeeding), with a towel underneath
- When breastfeeding: Place the potty under your bottom
- Larger babies: Classic squatting position over the potty
- At night: Small potty ready to hand next to the bed
ATTENTION: Never force your baby to stop. If she stretches or protests clearly, respect that. Holding off should be relaxing for both of you.## The right equipmentYou don't need much to start holding off. You probably already have a lot of it at home.
Retaining potty (Asian potty)
These little potties are specifically made for holding. They fit perfectly between your thighs while holding your baby. Known models:
- Classic Asian potty: Round, with wide rim
- EasyPisi: With splash guard, ideal for boys
- Enamel potty: Plastic-free and durable
- Foldable silicone potty: Convenient for on the go
TIP: To try it out, a mixing bowl or a sand play bucket with a round edge is sufficient. This way you can test whether social distancing suits you before you spend any money.
Practical clothing
Bodysuits are inconvenient to hold - they take too long to open. Better are:
- Two-piece clothing: trousers and top separated
- Split Pants: With opening in the crotch
- Leg warmers instead of tights
- Nightgowns or Zip-bottom sleeping bags## The advantages of the combinationWhy is it worth the effort? The combination of holding and cloth diapers brings tangible benefits:
Health Benefits
- Less diaper rash: Because the skin has less contact with excretions and gets more air
- Less colic and flatulence: The squatting position when restraining helps with the release of wind
- Less urinary tract infections: The excretions do not remain on the body
Formerly dry
Studies show: Children who are kept away often dry up much earlier. A Vietnamese study found that children who were kept from birth were dry by 12 months on average. For comparison: In Germany today, children on average only become dry at 28-33 months.
The reason is logical: diaper-free babies know the connection between body feeling and going to the toilet right from the start. You don't have to laboriously learn it again later.
Strengthened Bond
Paying attention to your baby's signals and responding promptly strengthens your communication and bond. You learn to “read” your baby better – even when it comes to other needs.
Sustainability and savings
Less wet diapers means less laundry, less water, less detergent. In combination with cloth diapers, you also save the mountain of waste from disposable diapers - up to 6,000 pieces per child.## Regressions are normalBe prepared: diaper-free is not a linear process. There are phases in which things work great - and phases in which nothing works at all.
Typical “strike times”:
- Development boosts
- Teething
- Illness
- New environment (vacation, daycare start)
- Learn to crawl and walk (baby is too busy)
This is completely normal and nothing to worry about. In these times, cloth diapers are your friend. Just wrap as usual and continue to offer the save in standard situations. After a few days or weeks everything levels out again.
TIP: Diaper-free is not a competition. It's not about using as few diapers as possible or getting dry as early as possible. It's about communication and recognizing your baby's needs.## Frequently asked questions### At what age can I start holding?Theoretically from birth. Many parents start in the first 3-4 months because babies then still show clear signals and are less distracted. But a later start is also possible - you can start at any time.### Does diaper-free also work at night?Yes, many babies do not eliminate in deep sleep. They become restless or awake when they need to. With a potty next to the bed you can also keep yourself safe at night. But: If it stresses you out, just use a cloth diaper at night.### Do I have to give up diapers completely?No, not at all. Most parents practice "part-time diaper-free" using cloth diapers as a backup. You decide when and how much you hold. Even just once a day in a standard situation is a good start.### What do I do if my partner or the daycare center doesn't participate?That's no problem. Your baby quickly learns that things work differently with different caregivers. You can do it at home and diaper changing will take place at daycare. The ability to communicate through elimination is not lost.### Isn't the baby too small for potty training?Diaper-free is not potty training in the traditional sense. It's not about teaching the baby something, but about responding to its natural signals. You don't train your baby - you communicate with him.## Sources
1. Healthy Habits: Diaper Changing at Home (CDC, 2024)
2. Elimination Communication: Diaper-Free in America – Pediatrics/AAP (2017)
3. Toilet training started during the first year of life – Rugolotto S. et al., Minerva Pediatrica (2008)
3. Vietnamese mothers' experiences with potty training – Duong T.H. et al., Journal of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics (2007)
4. Artrechte – the other baby book – Nicola Schmidt (2015)